Current location:International Infusion news portal > opinions
EDITORIAL: Top court ruling a step toward allowing same
International Infusion news portal2024-05-22 11:23:53【opinions】7People have gathered around
IntroductionThe Supreme Court has, for the first time, indicated that bereavement benefits provided by the gover
The Supreme Court has, for the first time, indicated that bereavement benefits provided by the government to support the families of crime victims could also be extended to same-sex partners, depending on the couple’s relationship and cohabitation situation.
This judicial decision on a lawsuit filed by the gay partner of a man killed in a crime marks a step forward in protecting the rights of same-sex couples.
The plaintiff, a man who had lived with his partner for about 20 years, applied for the same benefits granted to bereaved family members of crime victims after his partner was murdered in 2014.
But his application was denied on the basis that the victim was of the same sex, leading him to bring the case to the court.
The benefits in question are paid not only to spouses, children and close relatives of crime victims but also to partners who were in a committed relationship with victims that was effectively marital relations.
However, both the district and high courts that heard the case rejected the plaintiff’s claim on the grounds that relationships between individuals of the same sex were not covered by the program.
The Supreme Court's decision on March 26 clarified that partners in a de facto marriage are eligible for the benefits because, like spouses, they need support to alleviate the mental and economic impacts of their partner's death as a crime victim.
It stated that the necessity for relief in such cases does not automatically differ based on whether the cohabiting partner is of the same or opposite sex.
People cannot choose whether they love a person of the same or opposite sex.
”The pain of losing a partner to murder doesn't change whether they are the opposite or same sex. I thought it unfair that (same-sex partners) are treated differently," the plaintiff said at a news conference after the verdict, expressing a sentiment likely shared by anyone in a similar situation.
The Aichi Prefectural Public Safety Commission, which decided not to grant the benefits solely because the victim and applicant were of the same sex, must reconsider its stance.
There might be other cases where similar decisions were made or applications for the benefits were not accepted in other prefectures.
While this ruling directly affects only the future administration of the crime victim bereavement benefits program, there are more than 200 legal systems for benefit payments that treat de facto marriage partners as eligible.
These systems include the survivor’s pension program and the special pension program for the bereaved families of victims of work-related diseases and accidents.
Ministries and agencies responsible for these benefits and services need to reconsider whether automatically excluding same-sex partners from eligibility remains acceptable in light of this judgment.
However, even if the trend toward granting such benefits to same-sex couples continues to grow in the coming years, the fact remains that such couples will be treated only as being in a “de facto marriage.”
That means they will be excluded from the many benefits granted to legally married couples, such as tax breaks. In other words, adjustments to the rules concerning benefit payments cannot substitute for the legalization of same-sex marriage.
Regarding the provisions in the Civil Code and Family Register Law that do not recognize same-sex marriage, the Sapporo High Court earlier this month declared them unconstitutional in the first appeals court ruling in a cascade of lawsuits challenging whether these provisions are compatible with the Constitution.
Considering the need to deliver public services fairly to those in need, further delays in the legislative debate on the legalization of same-sex marriage are unacceptable.
--The Asahi Shimbun, March 28
Address of this article:http://southafrica.afischerphasedrives.com/html-65d699873.html
Very good!(6186)
Related articles
- Election deniers moving closer to GOP mainstream as Trump allies fill Congress, report shows
- Yao: NBA very welcome in China
- Big Chinese companies brighten 2024 CES
- Anderson aiming to dish out more assists
- At least 6 Egyptian women die after vehicle slides off ferry and plunges into Nile River
- Xizang marks milestone in green energy production
- Zhang Weili defends UFC strawweight title against Brazil's Amanda Lemos
- Xi Extends Condolences to Libya's Presidential Council Chairman over Deadly Storm
- Politically motivated crimes in Germany reached their highest level in 2023 since tracking began
- Referee reflective during third stint at FISU event
Popular articles
Recommended
Iran: Thousands mourn President Raisi and others killed in helicopter crash
Xi Extends Condolences to Moroccan King over Deadly Earthquake
Deals lure tourists before Spring Festival
Over 600 enterprises sign up for 7th CIIE
Iran's nuclear policy unlikely to change even after president's death
Cricket bowled over by big
Mountain boy's uphill battle to gold
Chinese police take back 130 gambling, scam suspects from Cambodia
Links
- Alcaraz injures ankle, exits Rio Open after 2 games
- AP PHOTOS: Paris Olympics venues mix history and modernity and showcase cultural heritage
- Jingzhou: a gateway to the fascinating history of Chu culture
- Set to win presidential election, Putin vows to achieve national goals
- Enjoy winter sports at foot of Great Wall in Shanxi
- HK, Macao children representatives visit landmarks in Beijing
- Judge orders psych evaluation for Illinois man charged in 4 killings
- Set to win presidential election, Putin vows to achieve national goals
- Jiulong Peak: A paradise of nature, knowledge and prosperity
- Apricot flower festival opens in Beijing's Yanqing district